Who's your Fav American Idol Judge? Who's your Least Fav? Why??

[Bruce Lee]

Actually, I think he was pretty dead on about The Spice Girls having no talent. They just so happened to craft a very successful pop record, but most pop musician's in general are extremely lacking in regards to tangible talent.

Many are entirely marketed on how physically attractive they are to the opposite sex, and the Spice Girls definitely were no exception to that themselves.

[fidget]

Simon is awesome. I always wonder if he's really such a jerk, or if it's acting for the show. I don't watch the show all the time, but when I do, he cracks me up.

[NonSenseSuperman]

Randy: unoriginal. seems like he's always trying to emulate simon.
Paula: Overly emotional to the point of it looking fake. Drives me nuts how she can't seem to form a cohesive sentence at times.
Simon: Too full of himself and has no amount of compassion.

Can I pick Ryan? :P

[dramaqueen]

Simon is my favorite because he tells it like it is. Yes, he has a different personality but sometimes I wonder how much of that is for getting ratings. It might be nice to know how he really is as a person. Paula is my least favorite. This season, especially, she has really started getting on my nerves.

[morph07]

I really love how Simon make comments. to the contestants.. its quite accurate and most of them were i agreed..

[Collyweed]

Simon gets my vote every time. I agree that sometimes he's too harsh in his criticisms but going up against the other two, there is no competition. No matter how bad and Paula still wants to say yes and I'm just plain tired of Randy's "dawgs".