Who's your Fav American Idol Judge? Who's your Least Fav? Why??

[Fullmetal_chick]

My Favorite is Simon Cowell, he's always honest to the point and tells it like it is if your bad or suck he won't sugar coat it, his comments are funny as hell also.

My least Favorite is Paula Abdul, she always cuts off Simon doesn't let him finish his comments, she appears drunk most of the time, she always comments on crap that has nothing to do with the contest like omg i love your hair and your outfit {Its a singing competition!}, and she's always has to sugar coat she doesn't know how to say anything bad even when it is.
I agree with you Toot, Im soo sick of hearing Dawg everytime.

[SweetyTweety]

Randy gets on my nerves- Hey Dawg Hey Dawg Hey Dawg.

[SakuraL]

Simon is terrific!! if he waasn't on, why would anyone watch?? Besides the bad auditions, he's the best part of the show..

[aperio]

I think it's all or nothing. I remember reading a year or so ago about how they were considering getting rid of Paula and who some possible replacements were.... but admit it, if any one of the judges were gone, it would never be the same, and we'd always be comparing them to the original.

Of the three, I like Simon the most. No nonsense, straight to the point, and usually pretty on target.

[Bruce]

Hands down Simon is the best. He's straight-talking and tells it like it is. I agree with his comments most of the time. Now Randy is plain boring and just too agreeable.

[Bruce Lee]

I don't even like American Idol much, but Simon can definitely be very entertaining at times.

Unfortunately for American Idol and it's contestants, I really have not liked any of them.

The musical styles they represent do little for me, although I do respect the talent of some contestants.

[CopyCat]

I really don't have a favorite, I've only watched the show maybe twice...
But I did want to step in here and say how much I hate Simon Cowell...
You would think a man of his success would not be so rude... There is
no reason for him to act the way he does... All the time rolling his eyes
at contestants for there singing abilities, or lack thereof... And criticising
contestants performance in the worst way... He could let these people
down softly, not insult them and try and make them feel 2 inches tall...
Well despite his successes, he refused to sign a contract with
‘The Spice Girls’ when they were first starting out saying they
had no talent and also ‘Take That’ simply because he thought
Gary Barlow was too fat to ever be a star...
Well he made some pretty big mistakes there...

[MovieAddict]

I think the judges of American Idol are great: one with the attitude (Simon), one with a soft heart (Paula), and one for being just in between (Randy). But as for the favorite judge of mine, that would be Simon. Although I myself would be hurt by his way of judging, I would rather have his honest opinion than the other two judges.

[Brennan]

I don't really have a favorite but I do enjoy watching how they interact.

Paula pretty much can't say no - ever. You watch the early rounds and she will find any possible way to reject the person nicely without saying no. Simon pointed this out at one point this season. That was funny. It seems this year Paula and Randy are kind of joining forces against Simon. Simon can take his negativity and cynicism a bit too far, but he is honest and he does know what he is talking about. People need to hear the bad and the good. If they don't know what they are doing wrong, they'll keep doing it that way and never learn/improve. Although, he could ease up on the commentary on people's looks. This is a singing competition, not a beauty pageant.

[playit]

I don't really watch this show anymore but I used to. My favorite has always been, Simon because even though he can be harsh and as Brennan said needs to stop the looks commentary, his remarks are always valid